Surely the AFL are grinning from ear to ear at how the results fell over the weekend, particularly those involving the most recent expansion clubs. Who would have thought 20 years ago that the first weekend of an AFL season would see victors hailing from Fremantle, western Sydney, Port Adelaide and the Gold Coast? In a weekend which looked like delivering a couple of pastings when teams were named on Thursday, the only blow-out came from the game deemed most likely to be the closest by the bookies. Unfortunately, this punter fell for it and tipped the ‘Pies. Sigh.
So with Fremantle making the grand final last year, Port winning a flag in 2004 and the Gold Coast and GWS on the verge of a decade of dominance, is it time to rate expansion in the AFL as a bloody good idea? If nothing else, what the results on the weekend show is that when it comes to laying the foundations for a successful footy side from scratch, the AFL are capable of doing an exceptional job. Although the draft concessions granted to the newest license holders were unprecedented – perhaps making it impossible for them to fail – the foresight shown by the game’s big wigs to foster long term success is surely worthy of a tip of the cap.
Yet if you’re like me and agree wholeheartedly with the idea of a truly national competition, the AFL’s expansion can’t stop here. While I am not suggesting that we go ahead and chuck in any more teams in the foreseeable future, we’d all be fools if we thought this is as good as it could get. It’s only been a few years but you need only walk the streets of Surfers Paradise to see the progress the Suns have already made, their merchandise easily outnumbering that of the Gold Coast Titans despite this part of the country deemed rugby league heartland. And although I’ve not been to Blacktown in the past 12 months, I’d be surprised if there weren’t a few more Giants flags waving down there this week.
Where might the AFL look next? For me the first choice has to be Tasmania. With a population of over 500 000 – who are already footy mad – it would be offensive if they weren’t included in any future expansion conversations. Sharing a franchise might be tricky given Launceston and Hobart’s traditional rivalry, yet one would think common sense would prevail and cooler heads should get it done. But given the AFL’s tendency to do these things in twos, the question becomes more interesting after consideration is given to the Apple Isle. I would love the AFL to tackle North Queensland and put a team in Townsville, but given the comparatively small population base and rugby league’s sheer dominance north of the Tropic of Capricorn and I fear this bone would be too big for even the AFL to chew.
In my mind that leaves WA. With a population hinged to a mining boom that is still simmering and two commercially successful clubs already in place the state clearly has capacity for a third club. Precisely where any potential franchise would call home remains to be seen, yet given Fremantle’s ability to play out of Subiaco when the city itself is 20 km away suggests the citizens of Perth are not averse to slight travel in order to get behind their teams – if you build it they will come.
Other possible franchise locations include Darwin and rural Victoria, however I am acutely aware of the struggles smaller populations can have in supporting an AFL franchise. Had it not been for the Cats recent successes there’s no telling how much farther they may have fallen financially. What’s more, I feel greater relocation of regular season fixtures to these AFL hotbeds will satiate their appetite for top quality footy, and this resonates with a view held by more than just myself that Melbourne cannot continue to support the nine teams it does presently. If clubs such as North, the Dogs and the Dees are after a quick earn to fix up their income statement this just makes sense for everybody.
So what do you think? I know I’m being very macro and long-term with these ideas but do you see this potential for the AFL too, or is the code fast approaching saturation point? I’m keen to hear your thoughts. Tweet us at @spultured, or comment below.
Like this? Check this
AFL 2014 Preview – 7-12
AFL 2014 Preview – 13-18
Walking the Line – AFL – Round One (Week One)
AFL 2014 Preview – 1-6