I was a bit taken aback when it was announced Australia had regained the top Test ranking for the first time since August 2009. I suspect Michael Clarke was too – he certainly looked a touch sheepish in his hometown, Sydney, where he was interviewed following the announcement. Grinning like a dog (or Pup) with a bone, Clarkey reassured us that the team’s focus would now shift on to building a legacy as the world’s number one ranked team.
It could be a very brief reign indeed. The ICC rankings system is a complex beast. South Africa play three Tests, one against Zimbabwe and two against Sri Lanka, before Australia’s next assignment, playing Pakistan in the UAE. If the South African’s wallop Zimbabwe (likely) and Sri Lanka (even money – it’s where they lost their last away Test series) then Australia’s ‘legacy’ will be shorter than Davey Warner’s temper.
If Australia is the number one Ranked Test side, it has a hollow ring to it. The most recent update to the rankings has devalued both South Africa’s stellar away form of 2012-2013, and Australia’s atrocious away form of the same period. These Australian’s are not number one in the sense that Steve Waugh’s Australia circa 2004, or Cook’s England circa 2012 were number ones. That said, this Australian team is really good. It’s a two-horse race between South Africa and Australia; England are a few traumatic years away from seriously challenging, Pakistan is too mercurial, India and Sri Lanka are batting heavy and poor travellers, New Zealand will be New Zealand and the West Indies: don’t even go there sistahh!!
So, South Africa and Australia: these are the three things that will decide who is top dog for the near future.
1) The Asian Tours
As Malcolm Knox said in his brilliant account of Australian Test cricket from 1993-2008, world champions who can’t win in Asia are really no world champions at all. South Africa has points on Australia here, squaring their past two series in Asia against Pakistan 1-1. This makes for better reading than Australia’s infamous 4-0 drubbing in India in 2012. South Africa has two Tests against Sri Lanka in July, whilst Australia has two against Pakistan. Both assignments have their pitfalls. Rangana Herath and Saeed Ajmal might end up deciding the world number one more convincingly than the ICC’s convoluted ranking system.
2) The captaincy succession plan
A good captain moulds his team in his image, and leaves an indelible legacy on the game. AB DeVillers or Faf du Plessis are on the cusp of inheriting the captaincy; Clarkey might be entering the autumn of his career. How DeVilliers/du Plessis and Clarke’s successor mould their future teams will determine much about the future fortunes of their respective teams. AB DeVilliers has revealed himself to be not quite the natural leader that everyone thought he was. He sometimes seems a bit laboured in his thought-processes; a sure sign he cannot, or has not yet learned to let instinct take over. He will take a few series’ to find his feet, and will never be as at ease as a Graeme Smith or Hansie Cronje. Faf du Plessis appears to be a lot more comfortable in the role, but is an inferior player to de Villers. Clarke’s replacement is firming up to be Steven Smith. Smith has good credentials as leader of the Sydney Sixers and will no doubt be closely watching Clarkey’s every move in the months to come. Points to Australia.
3) Rebuilding
Between Jacques Kallis and Graeme Smith, and Ricky Ponting and Michael Hussey, Australia and South Africa have haemorrhaged over 42 000 Test runs. How those gaps will be plugged by the next generation will be crucial. South Africa’s new wave includes Rilee Rossouw, Quinton de Kock, Dean Elgar and Colin Ingram. Of those, only Rossouw has no international experience and the others all have varying levels of international success. However, the bowling cupboard is a bit more threadbare, with only Beauran Hendricks promising to deliver the venom of Dale Steyn or accuracy of Vernon Philander. Meanwhile, Australia have the opposite problem: bowlers at a dime a dozen, and not a batsman in sight. Starc, Cutting, Cummins, Hazlewood, Coulter-Nile, Pattinson, Bird, and Sayers can all be champions in their own right. Meanwhile, only the Queensland duo of Chris Lynn and Joe Burns are doing enough to even warrant consideration. Split points.
Australia are number one currently, but there should be a big asterisk beside that. I think it’ll take about a year for someone to clearly gain the upper hand, and I think it will still be Australia. Two reasons: Steven Smith will be the best captain since ‘Tubby’ Taylor, and whilst you can save a match with batsmen, you can’t win a match without good bowlers. Australia have good bowlers, and a good chance of an extended run at number one, too.
By Alex Treacy
Tagged: 2014, Australian cricket, Cricket, ICC, number one Test ranking, sport